Pope's Remarks                                    




Students of the Islamic school 'Jamia Nuria Islamia' chant slogans

on a Dhaka street





P o p e's   R e m a r k s



Pakistani Muslims chant slogans to condemn Pope Benedict XVI

for making what they regard as "derogatory" comments about Islam


Pope Benedict XVI






Intolerance is okay if you're the Pope



Columnist, Historian GWYNNE DYER


September 20,  2006

New Zealand Herald


The foolish and arrogant remarks about Muslims show that the Pope is in need of a few lessons in manners


ON A SCALE of one to 10, Pope Benedict XVI's first attempt at an apology was barely a three. He said nothing himself, but on Saturday, Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone told the world that ``The Holy Father is very sorry that some passages of his speech may have sounded offensive to the sensibilities of Muslim believers''.


That didn't stop the protests that have been building since the Pope gave the speech last Tuesday to an academic audience in Germany, so on Sunday he tried again.


Speaking from his summer residence at Castel Gandolfo, south of Rome, he said: ``I am deeply sorry for the reactions in some countries to a few passages of my address at the University of Regensburg, which were considered offensive to the sensibility of Muslims.''


He's sorry for ``the reactions in some countries'' to his remarks, but he implicitly stands by what he said in Regensburg. So is the new Pope really anti-Muslim?


After the 9/11 attacks five years ago, the former Cardinal Ratzinger told Vatican Radio that ``it is important not to attribute simplistically what happened to Islam'', then he added that ``the history of Islam also contains a tendency to violence''.


True enough, but Christianity has its own history of violence: the Crusades, the Inquisition, the religious wars and several other detours from the path of peace and tolerance.


Just before he became Pope last year, Benedict declared that Turkey should not be allowed into the European Union because its Islamic culture is incompatible with the ``Christian'' culture of Europe.


But the real case for the prosecution rests on his invitation to Italian journalist Oriana Fallaci to visit him at Castel Gandolfo last September.


It certainly wasn't a religious visit, since Fallaci (who died last week) was an atheist, and her fame as a war correspondent and interviewer was decades behind her. But she carved out a second career as the most extreme anti-Muslim writer in Europe, producing two best-selling books since 2002 that vilified Muslims as dirty sub-humans who multiply ``like rats'', and portraying Islam as an irrational religion that breeds hatred.


The title of her second-last book, the one that presumably inspired the Pope's invitation, was The Force of Reason, which has at its core the argument that the West is rational and reasonable, whereas Muslims aren't. And there was the Pope in Germany last week, saying the same thing.


In his speech, he quoted from the Byzantine emperor Manuel II Palaeologus, who told a Persian visitor that ``spreading the faith through violence is something unreasonable ... God is not pleased by blood''.


So far, so good - but then Manuel asked his Muslim visitor: ``Show me just what Muhammad brought that was new and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached.''


He ended his speech, four and a half pages later, by quoting the emperor again: ``not to act reasonably, not to act with logos, is contrary to the nature of God,'' said Manuel II, according to his Christian understanding of God ``... It is to this great logos, to this breadth of reason, that we invite our partners in the dialogue of cultures.'' In other words, you Muslims are unreasonable people, but if you do it our way, we'll finally get somewhere.


Pakistan's parliament has unanimously passed a resolution condemning the Pope's speech.


Seven Christian churches in the Occupied Palestinian Territories have been bombed, set ablaze or shot at. A Catholic nun has been shot dead in Somalia.


Most Muslims are well aware that violence is an inappropriate way to protest against accusations that Islam is a violent faith, but why do they care what the Pope says?


Benedict needs a few lessons in manners, but the real reason for the uproar is that so many Muslims feel under attack by the West. Two Muslim countries have been invaded by the United States and its allies since 9/11, and another, Lebanon, has been bombed to ruins by Israel with full support from the US and Britain.


At least 20 times as many Muslims have died in these brutal wars as the number of Americans who died in the 9/11 attacks, and almost none had anything to do with that terrorist atrocity.


So the suspicion grows among Muslims that all this is not really about 9/11 at all, and almost any minor insult to Islam from the West - cartoons in a provincial Danish newspaper, a foolish quote by an arrogant Pope - is enough to trigger outrage from Morocco to Indonesia.


We haven't achieved a full-scale ``clash of civilisations'' yet, but we're making progress.


Gwynne Dyer is a London-based independent journalist whose articles are published in 45 countries.


2006 The New Zealand Herald





A worshipper holds a banner during a demonstration

against Pope Benedict after Friday prayers

in Ankara September 15, 2006


A young Hamas supporter holds up a copy of the Koran

during a protest against remarks regarding Islam made

by Pope Benedict XVI, in Gaza September 15, 2006.


Jordanian protesters attend a demonstration against remarks by Pope Benedict

in Amman September 18, 2006. The banner reads "Islam drove people

from the darkness and into the light".


Kashmiri protesters stand near a burning effigy of Pope Benedict

during a protest in Srinagar September 18, 2006.


Gunmen killed Sister Leonella Sgorbati at a children's hospital in Mogadishu

on September 17, 2006 in an attack that drew immediate speculation of links

 to Muslim anger over the Pope's recent remarks on Islam.




                                                        Roobdoon Forum               Back to Main Page